Reviewer Guidelines ( update)
Reviewer Guidelines
Double-blind reviewing is system followed by the Iraqi Journal of Pharmaceutical Science. All the steps of reviewing are fully electronic. The reviewers have to read the criteria for judging a submission's suitability for publication in the journal, which may include instructions for preparing an effective and helpful review. Reviewers will have an opportunity to provide comments intended for the author and editors as well as separate comments for the editor only within maximum three weeks first round . Reviewers will be asked to comply with the competing interest disclosure policy.
Reviewer Guidelines
Manuscript evaluation form
ID number: (used in all steps of publication): ( )
Manuscript title:
- Manuscript publication:
1-1 Has the manuscript been published anywhere else?
Yes No
If your answer is yes, please specify the reference.
- Scientific Quality
2-1 Does the abstract provide a concise and complete summary?
Yes No
2-2 Does the introduction cover the previous studies and aim of the present study?
Yes No
2-3 Is the language fluent and precise ?
Yes No
2-4 Are the number and quality of references appropriate?
Yes No
2-5 Are the figures and tables correctly defined and used?
Yes No
2-6 Is the overall presentation well structured and clear?
Good Fair Poor
- Scientific Significance:
3-1 Does the manuscript involve an original work that reflects research undertaken with integrity and honesty?
Yes No
3-2 Does the manuscript present a novel concept or idea?
Yes No
3-2 Does the manuscript represent a substantial contribution to scientific progress?
Yes No
Notes and revisions required: Please make a recommendation (Accept; Accept with revisions; Submit for review; Submit elsewhere; Decline; See comments).
Please view the PDF file for the review process.
